Turtle-deadly Fishery Is Not Sustainable
Thirty-five Conservation Groups Oppose Marine Stewardship Council Certification of Canadian Swordfish Fishery
Turtle Island Restoration Network and 35 ocean conservation groups have sounded the alarm to stop the certification as sustainable of a turtle-deadly swordfish fishery in Canada. See the letter. The press release that follows was issued today by Canadian groups leading the oppositon:
Halifax, NS_ In response to the London, UK based Marine Stewardship Council assessment report for the Atlantic Canadian Swordfish Longline Fishery, thirty five marine conservation groups from around the world have signed on to a letter opposing the certification.
The fishery, which takes place from April to November off the coast of Nova Scotia, catches and discards roughly 100,000 sharks and 1,400 endangered sea turtles every year with many thousands dying in order to catch about 20,000 swordfish. The assessment report has been prepared by a third party certifier, Moody Marine.
“That a fishery of this nature can make it through the certification process without requiring any substantive changes to its practices clearly shows a problem with the MSC standard” says Scott Wallace, David Suzuki Foundation.
“This certification will further erode public confidence in the MSC label, “ says Shannon Arnold, Marine Coordinator at the Ecology Action Centre. “There is growing consumer awareness and demand for sustainable seafood, but when fisheries that clearly have an impact on vulnerable species are deemed sustainable, one wonders what these certifications actually mean.”
Nova Scotia is also home to one of the last swordfish harpoon fisheries in the world, which is considered one of the most sustainable fishing gear types. The harpoon fishery received MSC certification last year, and is sold primarily to the US market, and to the retailer Wholefoods.
The purpose of the MSC is to give market benefits to sustainable fisheries. It is unclear what market benefit will accrue for MSC certified fisheries when the most egregious and the most sustainable fisheries are awarded the same ecolabel. Over 500 individuals have written letters to MSC raising their concerns about the certification of this fishery.
“This fishery has received a lot of attention – primarily because it is the first surface longline fishery in the world to seek MSC certification. This fishing gear is a leading cause of major declines in the global ocean’s predators and sea turtles,” says Arnold.
There are thousands of surface longline vessels operating throughout the world and Canada’s practices are no better than the rest. Today is the last day for public comment. Moody Marine will release the final report in about one month.
For more information
Shannon Arnold, Marine Coordinator, Ecology Action Centre
Scott Wallace, Sustainable Fisheries Analyst, David Suzuki Foundation
Attached: Expert Letter with 35 Signatories